BestProsInTown

Jewelry in New York

Jewelry in New York picked by BestProsInTown

10AM - 7PM

647 Lexington Ave, New York
Bianca Jewelers Jewelry

“I have a classic Movado watch that requires a jeweler just to open and change the battery. Bianca not only had the expertise to do that, but to see it wasn't the battery after all, and offered to send it for a repair estimate. A day or two later, the watch I was wearing lost a couple of hours (perhaps the stem was bumped?). I went back to change that second battery. They properly re-set it, saying the battery was fine. They wouldn't charge me for either assessment but could have charged me to replace the second battery without me knowing the difference. Maybe a small detail, but such expertise and ethics are precious. Bianca Jewelers' business approach is no doubt reflected in the quality of their jewelry as in their customer service. Would recommend them from baubles to batteries!“

5 Superb129 Reviews

10AM - 5:30PM

608 5th Ave #506, New York
Wasserman Jewel Galleries Jewelry

“Richard is wonderful! So polite and professional. Spent time with me and never rushed me. His showroom has quality items. Highly recommend him. Chris is great as well.“

5 Superb107 Reviews

9AM - 6PM

21 W 47th St, New York
Dream Gems Corp. Jewelry

“Five Stars – Amazing Experience!Shopping for wedding jewelry can be overwhelming, but Dream Gems Corp. made it a great experience from start to finish. I purchased my engagement ring and wedding band from them, and the craftsmanship is stunning—the rings are so beautiful. What I appreciated most was their attitude; they were completely open, patient, and not reluctant to work with us to make sure everything was perfect. If you are visiting the NYC Diamond District, definitely check them out!“

5 Superb102 Reviews

10AM - 6PM

64 W 48th St #1103, New York
Vale Jewelry Jewelry

“I can’t say enough wonderful things about my experience with Vale. From the very beginning, the customer service truly stood out—especially working with Ava. She made us feel heard, cared for, and completely at ease throughout the entire process.

The ring is incredibly special to us, as we created it as a 13-year wedding anniversary upgrade. From day one, we shared our budget with Ava, and she respected it every step of the way. At no point did we feel pressured to go beyond what we were comfortable with. Instead, she thoughtfully guided us toward a diamond that perfectly matched both the look we envisioned and the price we needed. That level of honesty and care meant everything to us.
What could have been an overwhelming process turned into something exciting, meaningful, and personal because of her. You can truly feel how much she cares about her clients and their stories.

And the ring itself is absolutely beautiful— a rose cut elongated cushion set in a simple yellow gold bezel engraved with my husband’s initials on the inside, something we will cherish forever! I’m so grateful we trusted Vale, and especially Ava, with something so meaningful. I would recommend them wholeheartedly to anyone looking for both stunning craftsmanship and genuinely heartfelt service.“

5 Superb101 Reviews

9:30AM - 5:30PM

1200 6th Ave, New York
Malidani Jewelry Jewelry

“Eli was great, helped us with the selection, explained everything, and the price was unbeatable. Thank you.“

4.9 Superb171 Reviews

10AM - 5:30PM

580 5th Ave Suite 631, New York
Daniel of Fifth Avenue Jewelry

“Daniel was fantastic to work with. He was extremely knowledgable and made what could have been an overwhelming process feel easy and enjoyable. The finished product came out absolutely stunning and I couldn’t be happier. What a great overall experience!“

5 Superb99 Reviews

9AM - 12AM

580 5th Ave, New York
B2C Jewels Jewelry

“This is the second time I’ve ordered from B2C Jewels, and both experiences have been incredible. I ordered my wife’s ring through them, and I honestly can’t express enough how grateful I am for their service, quality, and care throughout the process - especially Adam

Adam made such an important purchase feel smooth, trustworthy, and special. The ring turned out beautiful, and my wife absolutely loves it. I would highly recommend B2C Jewels to anyone looking for a meaningful piece of jewelry and a company you can feel confident ordering from.“

5 Superb98 Reviews

11AM - 7PM

15 W 47th St #803, New York
DreamStone Jewelry

“What a great experience from start to finish with DreamStone. Pricing is great, website has a very large selection and building a ring couldn’t be easier. I even needed the ring finished within two weeks because of a vacation and they were able to accommodate. Couldn’t be happier! Big Shoutout to Ethan who helped me through the whole process. He is great!“

5 Superb98 Reviews

10AM - 5:30PM

74 Bowery # 1, New York
J Sampieri Jewelry

“The most accommodating and amazing team to work with. They custom made my engagement ring with my now husband to exactly what he envisioned. They also custom made my wedding band to exactly what I imagined. We love working with John and his team. Highly recommend!!“

5 Superb97 Reviews

9:30AM - 5:30PM

29 W 47th St, New York
G Diamond USA Jewelry

“Gary and Mila were SO nice and did an amazing job removing my grandmas stone from her setting and appraising it! They did it all same day and we had a great time chatting with them.“

4.9 Superb133 Reviews

11AM - 7PM

859 Flatbush Ave, Brooklyn
Gold City Jewelry Jewelry

“My experience here was great. They took the time to explain details of different types of gold and the actual value of each pieces. When it comes to selling, the process was fast, easy, and seamless. If you are looking to sell your jewelry, I recommend Gold City Jewelry.“

5 Superb75 Reviews

9:30AM - 5:30PM

581 5th Ave 2nd fl, New York
Salvatore & Co Jewelry

“After purchasing a ring locally in Alabama, we experienced multiple issues that, frustratingly, could not be resolved by the store where we originally purchased it. I decided to look elsewhere to have the ring remade, and can I just say... W O W.

The professionalism, craftsmanship, and quality we experienced with Salvatore & Co. is hands-down the best experience we have ever had when jewelry shopping. Our salesperson, Liza, was absolutely amazing! I truly appreciated her candidness, patience, and communication throughout the entire process. Before the remake began, she provided CAD renderings so I could have a clear idea of what the finished ring would look like. There was one aspect of the design that I questioned because I thought it should be done differently than what was pictured. Liza assured me that their design was the better choice. I trusted her expertise, and I am so incredibly grateful that I did. It exceeded my expectations in every way possible.

I have now had the ring for over a year (yes, a delayed review but I believe feedback should stand the test of time), and I can honestly say I am more in love with it today than the day I received it. What made this experience even more significant was that, due to the distance (Alabama to New York), I was shipping my ring to people I had never met and trusting them with something that was both incredibly valuable and deeply sentimental to me. That can be a difficult leap of faith but, from the very beginning, Liza made me feel completely comfortable and confident that my ring was in good hands.

Finally, I should mention how fair and reasonable their pricing was. Considering the level of craftsmanship, attention to detail, and personalized service we received, I was genuinely impressed by the value. The quality and care they put into their work made the entire experience feel worthwhile from beginning to end.

I am eternally grateful to Salvatore & Co. (especially LIZA!!) for saving the day and creating the ring of my dreams after the major disappointment we experienced with our hometown jeweler. The craftsmanship is beautiful, the experience was exceptional, and I absolutely love that my ring is truly one of a kind. Thank you, Salvatore & Co. and LIZA, for turning an unfortunate experience into something so incredibly special. We are loyal Salvatore & Co. customers for life!“

4.9 Superb101 Reviews

10AM - 5PM

66 W 47th St Booth 20-21, New York
Landsberg Jewelers Jewelry

“Susan was fabulous, I had a wonderful experience today. She were very kind, patient, and helped me find the perfect bracelet.“

4.9 Superb97 Reviews

8AM - 8PM

20 West 47th Street Mezzanie, 20 W 47th St level 21, New York
A Y Jewelry Jewelry

“Ara did a marvelous and flawless resizing my engagement ring, the ring has never looked better. He was very attentive and made sure my ring fit perfectly, it was very quick too, I was in and out in 20 minutes. I will be coming back for all my jewelry repairs in the future.“

4.9 Superb96 Reviews

10AM - 5:30PM

18 E 48th St Suite 1201, New York
Peter Atman Inc Jewelry

“Great experience! Raj was super helpful and responsive in designing my wedding band exactly how I wanted it and for a very reasonable value. Very quick turn around as well, highly recommend if you're looking to make custom pieces for affordable pricing.“

4.9 Superb91 Reviews

10AM - 6PM

594 Broadway #1104, New York
Shahla Karimi Jewelry

“Have been married almost 2 decades but we both wanted new rings made. Had a custom engagement and band as well as a mens band designed and made at Shahla. We worked with Lexi who was very helpful and friendly! We have been wearing the jewelry for over a month now and I come to appreciate the quality of the design more and more every day as time passes. The prong design, thickness recommendations, custom band shaping, and stone quality were all perfect. Would definitely feel comfortable recommending Shahla Karimi, and Lexi, for anyone looking to buy predesigned or custom jewelry in the area“

5 Superb57 Reviews

10AM - 4PM

545 W 45th St 3rd Floor, New York
Gabriel & Co. Jewelry

“I love the quality of their jewelry. Beautiful pieces! Will continue to add to my collection with Gabriel and Co pieces.“

4.8 Superb103 Reviews

10AM - 6PM

580 5th Ave #1221, New York
Platinum Days Jewelry

“I commissioned Platinum Days for a custom ring.

(1) Finished product is absolutely top notch and easily the favorite piece that I own!

(2) Design, casting, and finishing were completed quickly and piece was delivered slightly ahead of promised date.

(3) Everyone at Platinum Days was wonderful about taking time to review all options with me and never pressured for sale.

(4) Their knowledge of precious stones and metals and refined taste help me craft a design I love!

(5) In a place as competitive as NYC’s Diamond District, Platinum Days will be my first stop for all my future jewelry needs and a recommendation that I will make to family and friends without reservation.“

5 Superb51 Reviews

11AM - 7PM

155 Spring St, New York
APM Monaco New York Jewelry

“Stopped by from just a walk but the store was beautiful and the collection as well. JR helped us around the store being super friendly and I found the perfect bracelet for me! 100% recommend!!“

4.8 Superb92 Reviews

10AM - 6PM

580 5th Ave #709, New York
Namdar Diamonds Jewelry

“Excellent quality jewelry, and absolutely stunning colored diamonds. Wonderful at communicating, with a high level of integrity. Would highly recommend working with Namdar!“

5 Superb48 Reviews

10AM - 6PM

50 Hudson St 2nd Floor, New York
Frank Darling Jewelry

“My fiance and I worked with Frank Darling to design my engagement ring last year (he proposed July 18, 2025). We had our first appointment January 2025, weren't quite ready yet to make the choice, but went back April 2025 to pick the diamond. We met with Lily Dora in Jan, and Olivia in April. My ring is a modified version of the Symphony setting, with smaller side stones and a euro shank. Overall we had a pleasant experience with the showroom, but will preface that initially, they did the engraving inside of the ring upside down initially, which cause my fiance a LOT of stress leading up to the proposal. In the end, everything was fine but did want to flag that as one tiny mishap in our entire experience.

We went back to Frank Darling for my wedding band, as they do custom bands! We worked with Roni to do a custom curved band to stack flush with my engagement ring, and we are SO thrilled with the design. Roni really understood our vision and was patient to get every detail right.

So happy and excited about wearing these rings for the rest of my life, and returning to Frank Darling for future milestone pieces.“

4.7 Superb159 Reviews

10AM - 5PM

30 W 47th St #502, New York
Grants Jewelry llc Jewelry

“Great experience! Raj was super helpful and responsive in designing my wedding band exactly how I wanted it and for a very reasonable value. Very quick turn around as well, highly recommend if you're looking to make custom pieces for affordable pricing.“

4.9 Superb55 Reviews

10AM - 7PM

15 W 47th St #809, New York
Simply Select Jewelry Jewelry

“Shawn has provided a phenomenal service for me throughout the past three years I've worked with him.

I had an issue with a wedding ring and he promptly found a solution for us. His products always come out better than I expected!“

4.9 Superb54 Reviews

10AM - 5PM

42 West 48th Street 16th floor, New York
G & G Jewlery Jewelry

“Great experience! Raj was super helpful and responsive in designing my wedding band exactly how I wanted it and for a very reasonable value. Very quick turn around as well, highly recommend if you're looking to make custom pieces for affordable pricing.“

4.9 Superb52 Reviews

10AM - 5PM

21 W 47th St, New York
Alebel Jewelry Inc Jewelry

“Great experience! Raj was super helpful and responsive in designing my wedding band exactly how I wanted it and for a very reasonable value. Very quick turn around as well, highly recommend if you're looking to make custom pieces for affordable pricing.“

4.9 Superb51 Reviews