Rotten Island Records

$ • Vinyl Records, Pet Friendly, Record Store

74 Orchard St Fl 2, New York, NY 10002

About Rotten Island Records

Rotten Island Records is a part of an arts collective, offering a cool and vibrant atmosphere with friendly staff. Customers praise the store's varied selection of hip-hop and vintage LPs, as well as its competitive prices. While the store's location may have changed, it is still recommended for a short visit if you're in the area and looking for records.

Photos

Add a Photo
Rotten Island Records
View All Photos

Reviews for Rotten Island Records

Write a review
  • Jan 2026

    Easily my favorite record store in NYC. Unique space and the people are super chill!

  • Oct 2025

    On floor 2. Decent collection. Bought one record.

  • Mar 2025

    A really nice store and very friendly staff. I definitely recommend this store.

Hours

Monday: ClosedTuesday: 12 - 8PM
Wednesday: 12 - 8PM
Thursday: 12 - 8PM
Friday: 12 - 8PM
Saturday: 12 - 8PM
Sunday: 12 - 8PM

Tips

accepts credit cards street parking dogs allowed bike parking

Location

74 Orchard St Fl 2, New York

Directions Call Website Suggest an Edit