Tips & Reviews for Bay Street Tattoo Co.

price range: average in-store shopping masks required accepts credit cards street parking, private lot parking bike parking

  • Oct 2021

    I got a navel piercing (belly button) and it looks great! The nice woman you pierced me made sure that I was comfortable and talked me through the process and how it'll feel. It was very fast and not painful at all! She then told me how to take care of my piercing and what to expect and if something happens (if the piercing comes out) she'll be able to take care of it. They are very clean and COVID cautious. Make sure to book an appointment because I believe they don't take any walk ins because of covid. If you're looking to get a piercing I recommend coming here.

  • Oct 2021

    I called in asking if Sheri could squeeze me in for a nose and 2 lobe piercings— she was able to right away! I came in and was there for maybe 15 minutes. She was was kind, informative, and comforting. The shop was super cute and clean. I will definitely be back for more piercings in the future and maybe another tattoo ??✨Highly recommend. ?

  • Aug 2021

    Wasn’t asked what earrings I would like to wear when my piercing was complete. Since I walked in and asked for what I wanted done. There was a list of reasons why they might not get the piercings to look identical. Only one of my ears was pierced and I was charged 50$… when it was 60$ for both. I would not recommend this place. I would even pay more for better service. I was also told to put contact solution to clean my ears so I wouldn’t get an infection.Service: Ear piercing



Monday: ClosedTuesday: 12 - 6PMWednesday: 12 - 6PMThursday: 12 - 6PMFriday: 12 - 6PMSaturday: 12 - 6PMSunday: Closed


Google Google: 4.8/5 Yelp Yelp: 5/5 Facebook Facebook: 5/5 BBB BBB: A+

Bay Street Tattoo Co.

322 E Bay St, Milwaukee

Directions Call Website Pricelist Suggest an Edit