Bay Street Tattoo Co.

Bay Street Tattoo Co. is a women-owned business established in Milwaukee in 1999. They specialize in custom tattoos, offering black and grey, color, and cover-up options. The shop also carries a wide selection of body jewelry, including pieces made from genuine gemstones, gold, and acrylic. Customers can request specific items not in stock, and the shop is happy to order or create custom pieces. The shop is known for its friendly and knowledgeable staff. Sheri is absolutely amazing, sweet, informative, and talented with jewelry placement. She is professional, patient, and kind, with clear explanations of procedures and thorough attention to safety and cleanliness. She took her time to explain how she would be doing the piercing and gave multiple options for locations to make sure customers were getting it in the best placement possible. She was so quick yet so gentle when it came time to do the actual piercing. The staff uses gloves and alcohol pads for cleaning, and provides detailed aftercare instructions, guiding customers through the cleaning process. Many reviewers mention the positive experience, highlighting the skilled service and welcoming environment. Customers appreciate finding reasonably priced jewelry for their piercings, such as for helix, tragus, and inner conch placements. Overall, the shop is highly recommended for both tattoos and piercings, with many planning to return for more services in the future.