Stay True Tattoo, McFarland, WI - Reviews (65), Photos (36)

About Stay True Tattoo

Stay True Tattoo is a professional tattoo shop in Madison that has been serving customers for over 10 years. All artists have over 15 years of experience and create tattoos in a clean, friendly, and comfortable atmosphere. Customers describe the shop as unique and inclusive, with exceptional customer service. The shop has received praise for its artists' ability to create detailed and beautiful tattoos, exceeding customer expectations. Stay True Tattoo is highly recommended by satisfied customers who appreciate the positive experience and quality of work.

Photos

Add a Photo

View All Photos

Reviews for Stay True Tattoo

Write a review

Apr 2026
The experience I had tonight with Shoes was probably one of the best I've ever had with any tattoo artist. I'm not necessarily shy.. but he did tattoo my butt on both sides. He was so beyond respectful and kind and we had great conversation. Not use to the level or professionalism he gave.
Mar 2024
Ava is freaking awesome! She is everything you could ever want in a tattoo artist. I also love that I can schedule a free consultation online since I don't like talking on the phone.
Jan 2024
I love this shop! Ava did a wonderful job on a piece she did on my arm. I have quite a few tattoos, and this is my best one. The shop is clean and friendly, and very professional. I felt very safe and comfortable. I really don't have a single bad thing to say, so they easily get 5 stars! I will be recommending Stay True to everybody. Thanks, Ava!

More Reviews

Hours

Monday: 12 - 8PM
Tuesday: 12 - 8PM
Wednesday: 12 - 8PM
Thursday: 12 - 8PM
Friday: 12 - 8PM
Saturday: 12 - 8PM
Sunday: Closed

Tips

price range: average by appointment only wheelchair accessible accepts credit cards accepts apple pay free wi-fi bike parking

More Local Businesses in McFarland

Permanent Make-up Designs & Lash Extensions by Mary

- 5910 Monona Dr, Madison

Tailor Made Tattoo

- 1337 Greenway Cross Ste 146, Madison

Steve's Tattoo & Body Piercing

- 1205 Williamson St, Madison

Best Pros in McFarland, Wisconsin

Location

5710 US-51, McFarland

Directions Call Website Pricelist Suggest an Edit