About Colt's Sports
Reviews for Colt's Sports
Write a reviewHours
Monday: 10AM - 6PM
Tuesday: 10AM - 6PM
Wednesday: 10AM - 6PM
Thursday: 10AM - 6PM
Friday: 10AM - 8PM
Saturday: 10AM - 8PM
Sunday: 11AM - 6PM
Colt's Sports has an excellent selection of sports memorabilia and collectibles, with a great and changing collection of various sports and non-sports items. The staff is very kind, friendly, and knowledgeable, happy to find items related to any player. Customers note the store offers something for everyone, from high-priced, high-value memorabilia like signed photos and championship rings to current Topps cards and unopened packets from decades ago. While some find items way overpriced compared to online values, others have found obscure bobble heads reasonably priced. The family-run business provides downright excellent customer service, with staff happy to talk to kids about collecting. Regulars make a point to stop in at Peddler's Village, often finding something unique to spend hours looking at.
Store owner is a nice older gentleman. He will talk to anybody with the same attitude, whether you are new or somebody that's been there a lot. Store is an absolute mess - but I'm not saying that's an awful thing. He has twice as much stuff in there as can really fit, and he knows where everything is. If you ask, he knows immediately if he has something. I've read about rudeness, I've been in there a dozen or more times over the past 6 years and I've never heard any rudeness that didn't come from a customer. You can do better with the prices online, but online vendors aren't paying rent for a store - and nothing is terribly expensive. I'll be back in soon to buy...read full review
Very solid store for collectibles and cards I just wish the prices were a little lower but the service here is great nice people behind the counter just the prices need to be a little lower
Bought a ball that was not authenticated yet. They gave me an authenticity guarantee for full refund if it was not authenticated. I sent it to JSA and they were able to authenticate. I will definitely go back for autographed memoribilia.