Real Estate in Windham

“If you’re buying in the Catskills, I can’t recommend Regina enough. She brings: real access to off-market inventory, straightforward, unbiased advice, strong negotiation skills, a deep understanding of the local market, reliability and great judgment under pressure
She’s not transactional—she’s a true advisor. We had a fantastic experience and are incredibly grateful for the outcome she helped us reach.

We’re a Brooklyn family who’d been hunting for a Catskills place—mainly around Windham and Hunter—for years. We were always pretty skeptical about working with brokers, so we tried doing everything on our own. After a few close calls with houses that had major issues (and even a land deal that turned out to be a scam), we realized we might need actual help.

We’d met Regina early on and kept in touch casually. Even before we officially hired her, she always gave us honest, unbiased feedback on every property we looked at. After the land mess, it was clear we needed someone who really knew the area, so we brought her on.

From day one, Regina worked with real urgency and tapped into a network we never could have accessed on our own. Within six months she was showing us off-market options, cutting through noise, and only bringing us places that actually fit what we wanted. No time-wasting, no pressure—just targeted, thoughtful guidance.

And it paid off. She found us the perfect setup: a beautiful home with slope views plus an adjacent vacant lot, close to town and minutes from the mountain. It wasn’t even on the market yet. Regina got us in first and negotiated a deal that easily could’ve turned into a bidding war if it had gone on the market.

We went into contract on Halloween and were hoping (maybe unrealistically) to close before Thanksgiving so we could celebrate with visiting family. A week before closing, some old permit issues popped up in the title search. Regina had everything sorted within 72 hours by pulling in the right people, and we closed the day before Thanksgiving—exactly what we hoped for.

Of course there were ups and downs (there always are), and this was even a dual-agency situation, but Regina handled everything with fairness, calm, and really sound judgment. We ended up with an amazing property at a fair price, in record time.“

“Working with Susan Miller and Mike Miller of Windstar Realty Group was a great experience. What they brought to the table was nothing short of phenomenal. We were first time homebuyers and we regularly and confidently tapped into Susan and Mike’s knowledge of the market and the overall process of buying a home. We found this extremely reassuring. After building a relationship with each of them, we knew that we could absolutely trust that they had our best interests at heart; and to us, that was so important. Flexible, accommodating and proactive are also words that I would use to describe these two beautiful, honest people. I would highly recommend either Susan or Mike.“

“The best in the business!Whether you want to build a home, buy or sell a home and need help managing your property!They have excellent staff ready to assist you.They have managed my property for over 12 years and I am completely satisfied.“

“Dont know which sister I love more . Always friendly and willing to help with anything, they make a great pair and definitely compliment each other.“