Reviews

Write a review
  • Briana Gaines
    Aug 2025

    Sam always takes amazing care of me with all of my piercings! She’s super down to earth and very professional. I recommend her to everyone we talk to about piercings. Thank you so much for being so awesome!

  • estefania hernandez
    Aug 2025

    We went in with our 1 year old daughter to get her ears pierced Sam toke care of us was really gentle with our daughter we where in and out fast , clean and of course professional would definitely go back .

  • Dalia Ramos
    Aug 2025

    I took my daughter in to get a piercing fixed that was not correct from another place. Sam helped my daughter and it looks amazing now. She was kind to explain the whole process to my daughter. We will only get our piercing from Sam ! Thank you !

  • Brittany Cain
    Aug 2025

    Sam pierced my 5yr old’s ears and was so so patient. The first ear was quick and easy, but then my girl didn’t want her 2nd ear done. After some convincing and Sam talking to her in such a sweet and calming voice, she got it done. I would highly recommend going to ATS and requesting Sam.

  • Jean
    Aug 2025

    Brought my 6 month old in for her first ear piercings,with Sam and I also received a tragus and nostril piercing she was friendly,quick, and very informative about everything she was doing! Shop was very clean and everyone was nice and friendly! I just moved here with my husband from California and I'm so glad we found American Tattoo Society. We will definitely be coming back!! 😊

  • Cammerade TheKidd
    Aug 2025

    Absolutely hoorid experience with the peircer Sam. What should have been a simple jewelry change turned into 30+ minutes of her digging around with a taper trying to find the hole only for to end up useing a needle to re-peirce the hole so freaking crooked the peircing is now ruined. This means removing the jewlery , waiting for it to heal and having to get it re-done by someone who actually knows what they are doing. Sam should in no way be touching people with a needle....ever. The insurmountable amount of pain she caused and the unforgivable level of unprofessional from Sam is mind blowing.

  • Jane Hendricks
    Aug 2025

    I don't want to leave a 1 star because it's not the shop as a whole, their front counter staff is always very polite, and I haven't had any problems with any of their staff I've interacted with before, but for the love of everything do NOT go see their piercer Sam. 10+ years of getting pierced and 30+ piercings later and I have never left an experience so absolutely baffled and livid. I went to just get a jewelry swap on a set of Dahlia piercings that Bri (who is an absolute godsend in the piercing world and has done almost 20 of my piercings, never once have I had a bad experience or complaint with any of her work) had done 2 days prior for longer posts. She removed the posts before placing tapers, spent minutes digging in my face trying to get both the tapers and jewelry back in, and yanked around the clamp attached to the jewelry in my face, at one point dropping the clamp while still attached to the jewelry in my face and almost sending me out of the chair in pain (to which she showed no concern for whatsoever). People make fun of me for never flinching, but I have never been in so much pain during any piercing or jewelry swapping process. She ended up repiercing the second Dahlia unbelievably crooked when she couldn't get the taper in, and the exit point is nowhere near where the old one was. I walked in with 2 perfectly placed piercings that I was very happy with and walked out in near tears with an incredibly crooked piercing that I have to hope I can salvage and have fixed, when it was just supposed to be a simple jewelry swap. I don't want to write this out of anger, and I don't want to just post a nasty hateful review, but anyone who values themselves within the body mod and piercing community should be informed about who they may be trusting with their bodies. I have seen quite a few different people before finding Bri, who I swear by with piercings and will never (especially now) see anyone else, and have never had such a negative experience as the one I just walked out of with Sam. And to get immediately defensive and try to argue with someone when they point out it's crooked (which it VERY obviously is) is just a big red flag to me, the body of your client should always be more important to you than your ego as a piercer.

  • Lizzie Locklear
    Aug 2025

    Chris did a fantastic job on my tattoo and was very easy to converse and talk with. Not once did I feel uncomfortable during my tattoo appointment. I will be coming back in the future.

  • Desirae Deaderick
    Jul 2025

    Chris T,

    He was so patient with me through the whole process and made sure I was comfortable the whole session. He did a sick coverup on my back. 10/10 recommend him.

  • maddie
    Jul 2025

    Got a pomegranate tattoo from my artist cory, would absolutely recommend him for any fine line tattoos you're looking at.
    Edit: came in for an eyebrow piercing, was pierced by sam and she was extremely thorough in explaining the healing and taking proper care of it. also went with my friend and she got a sternum tattoo from Cory, he was professional and did a great job on her tattoo :D wont go anywhere else for tattoos and piercings

Load More

American Tattoo Society of Fayetteville

5439 Yadkin Rd #118, Fayetteville

Directions Call Website Suggest an Edit

Hours

Monday: 11AM - 10PMTuesday: 11AM - 10PMWednesday: 11AM - 10PMThursday: 11AM - 10PMFriday: 11AM - 11PMSaturday: 11AM - 11PMSunday: 12 - 10PM