About Anna P. Jay | Fine Jewelry

Lovingly nicknamed "The Jewel Box," Anna P. Jay is a fine jewelry salon on Nantucket Island. Dedicated to sourcing exquisite gemstones and jewelry for life's special occasions, it is a must visit. Using her background in geology and luxury retail, the highly skilled gemologist hosts a rotating selection of female jewelry designers at her jewel box at 5 Washington Street. The store is a must see for creativity, style, quality & sparkle. Anna is the most friendly, most reliable jeweler on Nantucket. She is the go-to when shopping for someone special, with custom care and genuine care for every situation. Anna is so transparent and kind. Her attention to detail and customer service are unmatched. Whether it's a bespoke anniversary gift, an afternoon pick me up, or a repair, Anna is so helpful and communicates about every step. The most beautiful jewel of a store, filled with spectacular pieces.

Photos

Add a Photo
Anna P. Jay | Fine Jewelry
View All Photos

Reviews for Anna P. Jay | Fine Jewelry

Write a review
  • May 2026

    My family and I have so much love for Anna. I found her through social media and although we’ve never met in person feel as if we are friends. She’s so kind and incredibly thoughtful when designing custom pieces. Definitely recommend!

  • May 2026

    From small gifts to multiple custom pieces that we have designed together, Anna is a remarkable and personable resource for any jewelry you want for your wife or daughter(s). I could not recommend her more highly!

  • May 2026

    Anna is the best! Her custom jewelry and her selection in store can’t be beat!

Hours

Monday: ClosedTuesday: ClosedWednesday: ClosedThursday: 11AM - 4PM
Friday: 11AM - 4PM
Saturday: 11AM - 4PM
Sunday: Closed

Tips

 offers repair services

Location

5 Washington St C, Nantucket

Directions Website Suggest an Edit