This place has everything you need ! Make sure you check here first!
Alex
Sep 2025
We had a terrible experience with Cayce Mill Supply. After ordering and paying for a product, we were left waiting two weeks before being told it was discontinued. Instead of honoring their mistake and offering the “similar” product at no additional cost or even a discounted price, they gave us the runaround—first promising a refund, then telling us we’d have to pay more money for a product we didn’t even want.
On top of that, they expected us to pay a restock fee for the matching product we received that wasn’t discontinued.
Throughout the process, the staff was unfriendly, unhelpful, and downright rude. When we called to speak with management, Adam was smug, disrespectful, and showed zero concern for the situation.
Because they sold us a product without checking availability, we now have holes cut in our new shower/tub with no faucets to install and no comparable product we’re happy with. Their lack of professionalism and customer care has caused unnecessary stress and wasted time and money.
I would not recommend Cayce Mill Supply to anyone.
Keith Dwyer
Aug 2025
These guys are top notch. Been going there for the last couple of years and never had a bad experience, until today. Today I learned that trades people that see us in Caycee Mill are mostly helpful when asked a question. Well today as I was being helped with a septic tank riser, I asked a question about the riser fitting my model of tank and how it functioned. A trades person setting there was asked by a super helpful store employee, if he was accustomed using this type of riser and he explained how they worked. I was grateful for his assistance, until he asked, are you an installer? and I replied no, I'm a farmer. His response wasn't to me, it was to the employee. You see, this is what happens when yall sell these tanks to just anybody... I was a little upset with his response, but none the less, I stayed professional as my wife would say. And looked at my buddy and just laughed. As we were walking out, I could hear the guy say that being a farmer doesn't mean you know what you're doing. I just let it go and walked out. I plan on going in this place until I get finished with my project, and the employees at Caycee Mill were and always have been very professional and courtesy levels are always high.
Mean Dean
Apr 2025
My GoTo Place
Nicholas Irvin
Oct 2024
The staff were very helpful
Leszek Moskal
Oct 2024
Slow service
Samuel Yoder
Apr 2024
The staff at Cayce Mill Supply is great to work with. Friendly people!
Mason
Jan 2024
Not very good company they aren’t organized there employees spends weekends in jail for DUI they are not honest people and they care nothing about there employees
Chris Miller
This place has everything you need !
Make sure you check here first!
Alex
We had a terrible experience with Cayce Mill Supply. After ordering and paying for a product, we were left waiting two weeks before being told it was discontinued. Instead of honoring their mistake and offering the “similar” product at no additional cost or even a discounted price, they gave us the runaround—first promising a refund, then telling us we’d have to pay more money for a product we didn’t even want.
On top of that, they expected us to pay a restock fee for the matching product we received that wasn’t discontinued.
Throughout the process, the staff was unfriendly, unhelpful, and downright rude. When we called to speak with management, Adam was smug, disrespectful, and showed zero concern for the situation.
Because they sold us a product without checking availability, we now have holes cut in our new shower/tub with no faucets to install and no comparable product we’re happy with. Their lack of professionalism and customer care has caused unnecessary stress and wasted time and money.
I would not recommend Cayce Mill Supply to anyone.
Keith Dwyer
These guys are top notch. Been going there for the last couple of years and never had a bad experience, until today. Today I learned that trades people that see us in Caycee Mill are mostly helpful when asked a question. Well today as I was being helped with a septic tank riser, I asked a question about the riser fitting my model of tank and how it functioned. A trades person setting there was asked by a super helpful store employee, if he was accustomed using this type of riser and he explained how they worked. I was grateful for his assistance, until he asked, are you an installer? and I replied no, I'm a farmer. His response wasn't to me, it was to the employee. You see, this is what happens when yall sell these tanks to just anybody... I was a little upset with his response, but none the less, I stayed professional as my wife would say. And looked at my buddy and just laughed. As we were walking out, I could hear the guy say that being a farmer doesn't mean you know what you're doing. I just let it go and walked out. I plan on going in this place until I get finished with my project, and the employees at Caycee Mill were and always have been very professional and courtesy levels are always high.
Mean Dean
My GoTo Place
Nicholas Irvin
The staff were very helpful
Leszek Moskal
Slow service
Samuel Yoder
The staff at Cayce Mill Supply is great to work with. Friendly people!
Mason
Not very good company they aren’t organized there employees spends weekends in jail for DUI they are not honest people and they care nothing about there employees
Jason V Mr. Straight8
Always 5 star service
Jason V. “Mr. STRAIGHT8” Magsby
Always 5 star service