Skip to main content
BestProsInTown

Tillman Tire & Fast Lube

4.6 41 reviews
Overall rating
4.6
out of 5
41 reviews
5 star 93%
4 star 2%
3 star 1%
2 star 0%
1 star 4%

About Tillman Tire & Fast Lube

Tillman Tire & Fast Lube is a highly recommended business for tire services. They offer quick and efficient service, with no appointment necessary. The facility is clean and professional, and their knowledgeable staff provides excellent service at fair prices. Whether you need new tires, tire swaps, or other services, Tillman Tire & Fast Lube is a great choice for fast and reliable assistance.

May 2026
5.0
On vacation from Ohio, had brand new tires 3 days old
Picked up something at my destination, tire went flat. A wonderful stranger changed the tire for me (wrecker company wanted $250 and 90 minute wait).
The next morning on my way to Walmart to fix tire, happen to pass Tilmans turned around, went in said sure they could fix it. Took maybe 35 minutes charged $ 21 and I was on my way. Friendly, great experience.
Sep 2025
5.0
Great guys and service! They tried to help me out after hitting some road debris while on vacation! Couldn’t get a matching replacement tire after working on the damaged tire so suggested another dealer in Watertown!
Never charged me for stripping the tire off the rim and seeing if it was a viable tire! The damage was not able to be plugged or patched and drive on safely!
Would recommend them in a heartbeat!
Aug 2025
5.0
No appointments, first come first served. Neat clean facilities. Contentious and quick. Old school service provider at a very reasonable price. Wish I could find someone like this back home.
Tillman Tire & Fast Lube
All 1 photos

Hours

Monday 8AM - 5PM
Tuesday 8AM - 5PM
Wednesday 8AM - 5PM
Thursday 8AM - 5PM
Friday 8AM - 5PM
Saturday Closed
Sunday Closed

Location

36366 NY-37, Theresa, NY 13691

For local businesses

Is this your business?

Upgrade your profile to add the context customers, search engines and AI systems use to evaluate and recommend your business.

Write a review

Tillman Tire & Fast Lube · 36366 NY-37, Theresa, NY 13691

Your rating *

Write what you would want to read before calling. Please leave out contact details.

Photos optional

Add a photo

Tillman Tire & Fast Lube

Photos of the work, the vehicle or the premises. They appear on the profile once reviewed.

Call Directions