Best Barber Shops In Bay Shore

Below are the best 15 barbershops in Bay Shore picked by BestProsInTown

9AM - 8PM

1825 5th Ave, Bay Shore
Fifth Ave Hairstyling Unisex Corp. Barbers

“Fantastic barbershop! The guys here know what they're doing. I've always left this place feeling like a happy customer.“

4.9 Superb29 Reviews

9AM - 7PM

6 4th Ave, Bay Shore
Noble Savage Barbershop, LLC Barbers

“I cannot say enough wonderful things about our recent experience with Jonathan. My son had been growing his hair long for years, and when he made the decision to donate it, we knew it was going to be a big and emotional moment for him. We wanted to make sure the haircut felt special, meaningful, and that he walked away with confidence in his new look. Jonathan exceeded every single expectation we had, and I truly feel grateful for the experience he created for my son. From the moment we walked into the salon, Jonathan greeted us with warmth and genuine kindness. He immediately made my son feel comfortable and excited, which was so important since cutting off that much hair can be nerve-wracking. He took the time to ask my son what he envisioned for his shorter style, listened carefully to his ideas, and even offered professional suggestions to make sure the cut would suit his face shape and lifestyle. It never felt rushed; instead, it felt like Jonathan was giving his full attention to making the moment memorable. The donation itself was handled with such care and respect. Jonathan sectioned the hair perfectly so that it could be sent off without waste, and he explained each step so my son could feel proud about what he was doing. It wasn't just a haircut -- it was a celebration of giving, and Jonathan treated it that way. He even paused to acknowledge how meaningful it was to donate, which made my son feel proud and reinforced the importance of his choice. That thoughtful attention truly made the experience stand out. Once the long hair was gone, Jonathan worked his magic in creating the new cut. I was honestly amazed at how he transformed my son's look. The style was modern, clean, and absolutely perfect for him -- it looked like the haircut he was always meant to have. Jonathan shaped it in a way that framed his face beautifully, and you could see my son's confidence grow right there in the chair. He kept running his hands through his new cut and smiling in the mirror, which made me so happy as a parent. What really impressed me was Jonathan's attention to detail. He made sure every piece of the cut blended seamlessly, and he explained tips on how my son could style it himself at home so it would stay looking fresh. He even suggested products that would be easy to use without feeling heavy, knowing that teenagers don't want to fuss too much with their hair. It was thoughtful touches like that which showed Jonathan truly cares about his clients beyond just the appointment. The atmosphere throughout the appointment was relaxed, friendly, and professional. Jonathan has a natural way of connecting with people, and he made both of us feel at ease the entire time. My son walked out of that salon not only with the best haircut of his life but also with a boost of self-esteem. As a mom, that's all I could ask for. I have been to many stylists over the years, but Jonathan is in a league of his own. His combination of technical skill, artistry, and genuine kindness makes him truly exceptional. This was more than just a haircut -- it was an experience my son will remember for a long time, and it marked such a positive transition for him after donating his hair. If you're looking for someone who can deliver a perfect cut while also creating a memorable and uplifting experience, I wholeheartedly recommend Jonathan. Five stars doesn't feel like enough -- he deserves so much more. We will absolutely be back, and I'm so grateful we found him.“

4.8 Superb63 Reviews

9AM - 8PM

190 Howells Rd, Bay Shore
JR Barbershop Barbers

“Wow im absolutely amazed on how great verónica worked on my hair. The spot is also very clean, i was a walk in and immediately was assisted unlike other barbershops. This is indeed a gem that has come to bayshore. I suggest yall try this new spot out it is 10/10“

4.8 Superb21 Reviews

10AM - 8PM

127 W Main St, Bay Shore
Prime Barber Lounge Barbers

“Best Barbers on Long Island Ny great atmosphere great convo but most importantly great haircuts Po Is A God with them Clippers no barber in the Shop will let you down“

4.9 Superb10 Reviews

8AM - 8PM

32 5th Ave, Bay Shore
Canevaro Barbershop Barbers

“My favorite barbershop on Long Island. Willy always squeezes me in at last notice and always does an awesome job highly recommend“

4.7 Superb72 Reviews

9AM - 8PM

1589 Manatuck Blvd, Bay Shore
The Perfection Barbershop And Unisex Salon Barbers

“Fast and Professional. It did exactly what I commanded. Shout out to Pineda (I believe my barbers name was)“

4.8 Superb13 Reviews

9AM - 7PM

1373 5th Ave, Bay Shore
Tonis barbershop #2 Barbers

“Crispy cut and beard trim. Clean and great prices. Will be going back again for the next cut“

5 Superb5 Reviews

9AM - 6PM

2052 Sunrise Hwy, Bay Shore
Zohan Barber Shop Barbers

“Fantastic place.. highly recommend.. they're the Lamborghini of LI barbershops..“

4.7 Superb25 Reviews

8:30AM - 6PM

Target Shopping Center In-between Staples and Verizon, 864 Sunrise Hwy South Service Rd, Bay Shore
Twins Barber Shop Barbers

“Came in for a cut on a Sunday morning, Tara was my barber and she gave me a perfect cut. Got exactly what I had asked for, quickly and perfectly executed. Pricing was fair. I will be coming here from now on to have her do all my haircuts.“

4.7 Superb23 Reviews

10AM - 8PM

1566 Brentwood Rd, Bay Shore
Major League Barbers Barbers

“Dizzy the man there def check this spot out chill environment makes you feel welcomed“

4.6 Superb5 Reviews

9AM - 8PM

1845 Union Blvd, Bay Shore
Corporal Heighter's Sports Barbers

“Went in on a whim to get a fresh beard trim and line up. This is a classic corner barbershop with talented barbers and a nice relaxed atmosphere. The prices are reasonable and my guy Dru (Drew?) really took his time and absolutely hooked me up with one of the best trims I’ve gotten in a while. I highly recommend this spot and will be back soon.Services: Custom cut“

4.4 Superb18 Reviews

10AM - 8PM

1645 5th Ave, Bay Shore
Salvador Barber Shop Barbers

“Salvador is the owner and main Barber. He is incredibly professional. Punctual and efficient. Been to so many barbers that are never on time and take an hour for a cut and shave. Salvador has me out in 30min, and is usually within 5minutes of scheduled time.Make an appointment with him or his son“

4.4 Superb23 Reviews

10AM - 7PM

1545 Brentwood Rd, Bay Shore
Mojica Barber's Shop Barbers

“Hair cut and shaving was so quick, good and perfect. Very friendly and great barbers.“

4.2 Good12 Reviews

10AM - 7PM

1784 5th Ave, Bay Shore
La Excelencia Barber Shop Barbers

“First time here, I had called in advance to see if they’ll still be open around 6pm. The person who answered the phone was pleasant told me to come on over. When I arrived I was immediately greeted by the first barber big smile and all.

I was lucky enough to be able to sit down right away, Ignacio one of the barbers was available and I’m glad he was. He did an AMAZING job. Full service haircut. He took his time and knew exactly what he was doing. Even when he responded to a few questions from random conversations going on he was 1000% focused. I got a trim, tape up and shave with blade and NOT ONE cut.

I’d highly recommend you stop by and check it out for yourself. Great customer service but more importantly great SKILLED BARBERS!“

4.3 Superb23 Reviews

9AM - 8PM

91 Howells Rd, Bay Shore
Kut Kings Barber Shop Barbers

“Went to Lance last week for a buzz and beard trim. Very professional, fast, and great service.“

3.7 Good22 Reviews

Related Categories