My husband and I just had the pleasure of working with Donna while buying a premier property in Summerland Key. Donna was always available via text or phone call to answer any questions we had as we went through the process. She went above and beyond to seek out information for us, tend to details that were areas of concern and to make us feel we were valued clients. Donna is an excellent communicator and demonstrates thoughtfulness through her words and actions. A true professional.
About Donna Pezzi - REALTOR
Donna Pezzi, a realtor with Keller Williams Key West Compass Realty, is highly regarded in the Middle and Lower Keys real estate market. She has earned recognition for her expertise, integrity, and client-centric service since 2009. Donna has a reputation for diligence, creativity, and trustworthiness. She provides comprehensive services that cater to the unique needs and lifestyles of her international clientele. One client states that dealing with Donna Pezzi was by far the best choice of a realtor professional they have ever dealt with. She is very up front with constant contact information on your property with any concerns and working in your best interest continually. If you are buying or selling property, especially in the Florida Keys, with all the ins and outs of various guidelines, she's the one you want to contact, you won't be disappointed. Another client received five star service from Donna Pezzi. She was so fast and informative and kept them updated all along the sale. They are so happy they did business with her and will be doing more business with her. Donna has been a trusted realtor from the very beginning, helping clients both purchase and now sell their home. Her dedication and warmth made what could have been a stressful process feel completely manageable. Donna’s patience and understanding were evident every step of the way, as she took the time to really listen to their needs and guide them with care. Clients are beyond grateful for her expertise and the personal touch she brought to every aspect of their journey. If you're looking for someone who truly cares about your experience and will go the extra mile, Donna is the realtor you want by your side. In summary, Donna Pezzi offers exceptional real estate services, characterized by industry expertise, local knowledge, and a genuine, people-first approach.
Reviews
Donna is one of the best realtors I have ever dealt with. She is very knowledgeable about the Florida Keys and the properties. My spouse used her years ago with the purchase of another property and had the same experience. Donna was extremely helpful throughout the purchase process especially and didn’t hesitate to go to the property anytime to take pictures of things we had questions about since we were back at our home out of state. She followed the lending process all the way to the end and made sure that everything went smoothly. If you are looking for a knowledgeable and trustworthy realtor who wants the best for her clients, look no further. Give Donna a call.… read full review
Working with Donna to sell my home on Little Torch Key was truly an exceptional experience from start to finish. What I appreciated most was her unwavering commitment—this wasn’t a quick sale, but rather a relatively long journey, and she never once lost focus, energy, or optimism.
Donna navigated every twist and turn of the market with professionalism and expertise. From strategic pricing adjustments to creative marketing and consistent communication, she kept me informed and confident every step of the way. Her deep understanding of the Keys market and waterfront properties really set her apart.
What stood out most was her persistence and dedication. Even when… read full review
Photos

Hours
Location
333 Fleming St, Key West, FL 33040
Similar Pros in Key West
You May Also Like
Is this your business?
Upgrade your profile to add the context customers, search engines and AI systems use to evaluate and recommend your business.
